fbpx
Secured Credit Cards: What You Need to Know Josh January 28, 2021

Secured Credit Cards: What You Need to Know

Credit cards are a great way to earn cash back and travel rewards. But naturally, in order to benefit, you need to get approved for credit.

As you aim for premium credit cards, there are some barriers to entry, such as income, spending, and perhaps most importantly, your credit score. There’s no shortcut to fixing this, and it’s a bit of a chicken-or-egg problem: you need good credit history to be approved for more credit, but you need to have credit to demonstrate responsible credit usage.

For people with a weak credit history, secured credit cards are a great way to get started, building a healthy foundation that will make you more attractive to lenders for all sorts of purposes.

What Is a Secured Credit Card?

Secured credit cards are almost exactly the same as regular credit cards, except you need to leave a cash deposit at the issuing bank to cover the entire credit limit. For example, for a limit of $1,000, the bank would ask for a $1,000 deposit.

You can effectively set your own credit limit, based on the size of your deposit. If you try to spend over your limit, the transaction will be declined.

Secured cards present minimal risk to the issuer. If a cardholder defaults on their debts, the bank will keep the security deposit. That way, the bank is guaranteed to get paid.

Some issuers, typically smaller ones, have specific products that they market as secured cards. Many of them don’t have rewards, such as the Home Trust Secured Visa Card for no annual fee. Others have low rewards or low interest rates, but with an annual fee, like the Plastk Secured Visa Credit Card, for a $120 annual fee and 1% cash back on purchases.

Larger banks offer a selection of their regular credit card products, with an option to secure them.

Depending on the bank, you may have different options for how to store your security deposit. Some banks treat it as a locked balance in a chequing account. For example, if you have $2,000 in a chequing account, of which $500 is guaranteeing a $500 limit on a secured card, the spending power in your chequing account is only $1,500.

You might also be able to keep your security deposit in an interest-bearing account. TD lets you put it in a GIC, which is a nice perk while that money is idle anyway.

How Do Secured Credit Cards Work?

After you pay your deposit, secured credit cards work exactly the same as other credit cards. As long as you make regular payments, you won’t even notice a difference.

You make purchases on the card, up to your monthly credit limit. At the end of each billing cycle, you’ll receive a statement. Pay the full balance before the due date to avoid penalties and interest.

You must make at least the minimum payment to have a positive report to the credit bureau. Like any other credit card, late payments will have a negative impact on your credit score.

If you don’t pay your balance in full, a portion of your security deposit will be used to cover any interest, and your limit will be reduced accordingly.

After 6–12 months of good history, your issuer will unlock your security deposit, upgrading the card to an unsecured card. At that point, or earlier if you close the secured card, you can withdraw the secured balance.

Who Should Get a Secured Credit Card?

Regular credit cards are unsecured, meaning that the issuing bank will take you to collections if you default on your debts. While this poses a risk to the bank that they might not get the money they are owed, they are willing to extend unsecured credit on the basis of an applicant’s strong track record of repayment.

On the other hand, if you have poor credit or no history, you’ll have trouble convincing a bank to lend to you just on the basis of a “promise” to repay, without any collateral. In particular, students, new immigrants, or anyone recovering from some bad debts might find themselves in this situation.

Secured credit cards are a great way to build or repair your credit history. They report to the credit bureaus and contribute to all of the same factors as other revolving credit accounts, like record of repayment and age of accounts.

Many secured cards are marketed at people with poor credit. Banks specifically advertise guaranteed approval, a minimum credit score of 300 (which is the lowest score possible), or that you’ll be approved if you’ve recently been discharged from bankruptcy.

If you’re having trouble getting approved for other cards, using a secured credit card will help. Usually your credit score will improve significantly within 12–18 months.

If you must, you can also carry a balance on a low-interest secured card, and your credit health will improve as long as you make the minimum payment on time. However, even at a low interest rate, it’s probably better to clear your debts first, and then begin rebuilding your credit once you’re in the black.

How to Benefit from a Secured Credit Card

The main reason to get a secured credit card is to improve your credit score and to build a positive relationship with the issuing bank, particularly if you’re having trouble getting approved for other cards or loans.

Basically, the bank wants to see that you’re using your credit limit responsibly. Low utilization is key – small purchases like lunch or coffee, paid in full at the end of your billing cycle. Generally, it’s best for your credit history if you keep your monthly statement balance under 30% of your credit limit.

Remember, your long-term banking relationships and the health of your credit file take precedence over short-term spending power, as they can be leveraged into bigger rewards on better cards down the road.

In fact, when it comes to approvals, I’d say a good relationship with the bank is more important than your credit file. After all, the bank is the one determining and bearing the risk of lending to you – they’re the party you need to convince.

That said, a good credit file is still necessary to carry your strong relationship from one bank to another. Luckily, you can work towards both goals in tandem.

Even if you do have good credit history, not all issuers use the same criteria for credit card approvals. Banks use an internal score to evaluate clients, incorporating your credit history with their own factors, which may weigh your history with the bank more heavily.

For instance, one year of on-time repayment and low utilization might be sufficient for American Express, but not for HSBC. If you’re rejected by a bank with tougher lending requirements, consider asking a banking advisor if you can push the application forward on the basis of a security deposit.

Notably, I’ve heard that TD, HSBC, and BMO all award the full signup bonus and regular earn rate on spending, even if you have to put down a security deposit to be approved. That way, you can get bonuses from premium cards that are otherwise out of reach due to various credit factors.

Also, it’s all too common to run into an identity mismatch between the bank and the credit bureau. As that’s usually not a quick fix with TransUnion or Equifax, you can ask about opening a secured card to build positive history with the bank while you wait for your good credit history to be linked properly. That way, you won’t fall behind on your rewards goals.

Other Ways to Build Credit History and Earn Rewards

A strong relationship with your bank can do wonders for your credit journey. As a lifelong client at TD with a stable record of saving, I had no trouble getting a basic unsecured credit card at the age of 18, and premium products by 22.

Not everyone is so lucky, and many people make financial missteps at a young age. My friend Rohin missed a payment years ago, and it’s still hurting his credit file. Don’t be like Rohin!

Fortunately, Rohin’s a clever guy, and he figured out how to earn meaningful rewards in spite of this. Be like Rohin!

First, prioritize issuers that are known for easy approvals. American Express comes to mind, and MBNA also has a reputation for marketing to students. Both have highly desirable rewards on some of their cards, in the form of Membership Rewards points or Alaska Mileage Plan, respectively.

Likewise, stay away from issuers that you don’t expect an approval from. That way, you’ll avoid unnecessary credit inquiries (which could be quite hurtful if your score is already low), and you won’t have to go to great effort trying to push an application through, only to come out empty-handed.

If any part of your credit story needs to be explained, it’s best to meet with a banking advisor, as the online application algorithm will probably reject you right away. Even if you have newer accounts in good standing, a bad mark on your file is enough to trigger a thorough manual review.

Be prepared to explain the situation that led to your late payments, and why you’re seeking credit now. Also, you may need to show evidence from the issuer or collection agency that any delinquent accounts have been paid in full and closed.

If you have a reasonable story about the bad mark on your file, and a spotless history since, you should be able to open premium products. Rohin has had success opening various unsecured accounts at a handful of big Canadian banks.

Whether you’re working with no credit or poor credit, having a personal connection at the bank can’t hurt. See if you can use a family member’s assets, a personal relationship with a banker, or even your own deposit accounts to push things forward with confidence.

Even newcomers to Canada can use this strategy. Many banks offer a new immigrant package, with free chequing and a secured credit card. If you can’t or don’t want to lock up a security deposit, skip the secured card and just open the chequing account. Later, you might be able to use the banking relationship you’ve built, plus an employment contract demonstrating stability, to be approved for unsecured credit.

Whichever route you choose, it’s definitely helpful to work with a human at the bank if you anticipate any hurdles.

Conclusion

Secured credit cards aren’t for everyone, but they’re an incredibly useful tool if you need to build or rebuild your credit.

A healthy credit history is important for getting approvals for loans, mortgages, and credit cards, and new credit cards can be easily leveraged into bigger travel and cash back rewards. A record of responsible credit usage goes a long way to building strong banking relationships, which will benefit you in all sorts of ways, no matter how you choose to grow your wealth.

If you’re interested in getting a secured credit card, I’d suggest getting one from a Big 5 bank that will allow you to upgrade it in the future. You’ll probably want to keep it open long-term as one of your oldest accounts, and bigger institutions generally offer more flexibility and a wider variety of products. That way, you can continue to benefit from perks and higher rewards rates, long after the card has graduated to its unsecured form.

Top Offers

American Express Business Platinum Card

75,000 American Express Membership Rewards points
upon spending $7,000 in the first three months

  • 1.25x MR points on all purchases
  • Points transfer to Aeroplan and British Airways Avios at a 1:1 ratio
  • Unlimited Priority Pass access
  • Marriott Gold Elite status
Signup bonus
75,000 MR points
Annual fee
$499
8 Comments
  1. Avatar
    Roger

    Would you have any tips on getting a credit card from Chase bank USA? I have excellent CDN (837 Transunion) and USA credit (798 Transunion and 785 Equifax), an ITIN, a US mailing address, an RBC Bank (Georgia) savings account and Signature Visa and yet when I tried for a Chase card Feb, 2020- I got declined. I have since then obtained a TD Bank (USA) credit card and a Capital 1 (USA) card – the Capital 1 was originally a secured card and now – after a year they converted it to a ‘regular’ unsecured card. I also have a CDN AMEX that I could switch to the USA Amex. I saw where opening a savings account with Chase might be yet another way to do it and may go that route next unless you figure the TD Bank and Capital 1 cards (and perhaps the Amex switch) ought to change the Chase decision next time I apply.

    1. Avatar
      Jay*

      Length of credit history is the main culprit for Chase denials (typically, minimum a year). As well as depending on which card you apply for (CSP/CSR) they like to see you being able to manage cards with a 5/10k CL, since that is the minimum credit issued for those 2 cards.

    2. Josh
      Josh

      I’m not sure if Chase would let you do a secured card, but they are known to value the customer relationship – opening a bank account with them would likely help. Also try raising your limits on your other US cards – they like to see responsible credit usage.

  2. Avatar
    Pat

    I’ve had no luck getting the AP VI from TD (student, no prior relationship with TD) so I was thinking of going the secured route. Unfortunately, they don’t offer a secured version of that particular card, as seen in one of the screenshots in this post.

    “After 6–12 months of good history, your issuer will unlock your security deposit, upgrading the card to an unsecured card.”

    Does TD do this? If so, then would it be possible to get the FCT or CB VI secured and then PS to the AP VI once they make it unsecured?

    TIA!

    1. Josh
      Josh

      You should make an appointment with an advisor and ask if you’re eligible for a secured AP Plat (easier than VI as a student with no TD history). I know of one person who’s done it, and I’m not sure how strict or recent that list is.

      Once the card is unsecured, you can PS like a regular card. Maybe even while it’s still secured, again depending on how they actually enforce product restrictions for secured cards.

      1. Avatar
        Patrick

        Thanks for the suggestion! I actually met with an advisor a few weeks ago and was told that they don’t secure any of the AP cards. She did say it would be no problem securing any of the other cards though, including the FCT and CB VI.

        She also said that they do not approve students for any unsecured VI cards. Funnily enough, my gf has her own AP VI (lifelong TD customer)…

        Quite frustrating as I have a strong credit file and meet the income requirement from co-op income. I might just get a no-fee card to build up a relationship and hit the ground running once I graduate. Any DPs or suggestions?

        1. Josh
          Josh

          TD in particular is much more generous with existing clients. They’ve also tightened up their lending standards through the pandemic, more than most other banks. Bide your time with them, and for Aeroplan, focus on Amex MR cards or try your luck with CIBC.

          1. Avatar
            Kaz

            Just to add my DP on this thread, I’ve had similar experience with TD. Not really the same because instead of a student I’m a non-permanent resident in Canada, to whom TD never issues an unsecured card, hence none of AP cards. I tried around by calling a CSR, and visiting a branch multiple times but it never worked out even though I do have chq and sav accounts with them. Although my score wasn’t excellent, it was between good and very good. So I had to give up to get it from TD. As my story above happened before the AP renewal (and also before pandemic), I was hoping that they release the AP cards for secured one, but from Pat’s experience they didn’t change it at the same time as the AP renewal.

            What I did eventually was to try my luck with CIBC and it worked out. Not just for a secured one but they accepted me for a non-secured AP VI, without any CIBC history. So I suggest CIBC as Josh said above because these AP cards are basically the same.

            Speaking about the TD, they never release the secured fund from your account until one gets permanent residency (PR) even after the customer builds a good history > 1y with them. So I really don’t recommend new comers to get any card from TD before getting PR, because it can take a long time to get PR. Other banks can release the fund eventually. My first ever Canadian CC was from BMO which was secured initially but they released the fund after 1y of good history. CIBC accepted me for a non-secured card from the first place as I wrote above.

Josh

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have an Account? Click here to Login